This CD reissue contains all of Horowitz' stereo RCA Chopin recordings, along with a few mono items.
Chopin's Polonaise-Fantasy was a Horowitz specialty for many years. He
was playing this piece as far back as the 1920s, when few pianists
dared to touch such a structurally complex work. His best recording of
this piece remains the 1966 version taped lived in Carnegie Hall. This
can be found on Volume 3 of Sony's complete Horowitz issue. The 1982
version is among the most mannered playing Horowitz ever approved for
commercial release. The phrasing and metric pulse sag, and the piece
fails to cohere.
Chopin's Ballade in g minor was another piece Horowitz played
constantly. Again, his best version of this work can be found
elsewhere, including Volumes 3 (1965) and 4 (1968) of the Sony set. The
aforementioned problems are also in evidence here. In addition, some of
Horowitz' playing is technically sub-par, with an awkward coda that
sounds banged.
Horowitz' treatment of the nocturnes was his least successful Chopin
playing. Instead of letting the works unfold simply and naturally, as
Arthur Rubinstein did, Horowitz felt the need to soup-them-up with
distorted phrasing and exotic voicings. This group of four nocturnes,
recorded in 1957, are further sabotaged by "under the lid" microphone
placement.
Horowitz recorded the Barcarolle several times. His 1980 live recording
contains the typical Horowitz mannerisms of that period, with an
erotically charged coda. The old charmer is present for the "Black Key"
Etude, while the c-sharp minor Etude is given rather perfunctory
treatment.
Horowitz seemed more at home in Chopin's Ballade #4 than he did in the
first Ballade. The phrasing, dynamics, and dramatic build up are just
so "right" here, that one can scarcely imagine a better
performance--even with the occasional minor slip of finger.
The Chopin Waltz combines both--very different--editions of Chopin's text, with perhaps a dash of Horowitz' melancholy.
The sound quality varies, which is understandable considering the range
of recordings times and venues. These performances have already
received multiple releases on CD. One wishes RCA would do Horowitz'
memory a real service--instead of merely exploiting it--and undertake a
full Horowitz reissue as they've done for Rubinstein and William Kapell.
Hank Drake from Cleveland, OH United States , November 6, 2001