1978 LP MCA 2302
1978 CS MCA 35038
1998 CD Polygram International 800092
Recording Studios: Strawberry Studios, Stockport
Recording Dates: March to June 1977
Title:
Gone To Earth really stemmed from the artwork, which suggests an
animal's retreat from which it can watch the world outside. "Gone to
earth!" is, of course, the traditional hunters' cry when a fox manages
to reach its home.
Sleeve:
The cover was designed by Maldwyn Reece Tootill, and the original LPs
had the entrance to the fox's earth cut out so that the full-colour
inner sleeve showed through. This had the famous owl against the moon
on one side, or, if reversed, showed the same scene by day. The inner
bag also included full lyrics (more than full, in fact, as there is an
extra verse on "Love Is Like A Violin" which did not appear on the
finished recording!). A few copies of the LP escaped without the hole
having been cut out, so the centre of the front cover is merely an
enigmatic white blob!
Later pressings of the LP dispensed with the cut-out sleeve and simply
printed the owl as an integral part of the design, and this is also how
all cassette and CD copies have appeared. The montage on the back of
the sleeve was put together by the band with David Rohl, and the photos
were taken by Christopher B.Roberts.
A later reissue of the album from Korea was retitled Poor Man's Moody Blues and had a completely different cover.
Last words from Woolly:
"a lot of good things came together on Gone To Earth - some of John's
best, like "Poor Man's Moody Blues" and "Hymn" and Les's "Spirit On The
Water". There was a nice balance, the artwork was good and somehow
everything happened at the right time."
The group's best album, featuring some of their most effective hard
rock and their best tunes. John Lees' soaring, poetic "Hymn" became a
major part of their stage act, but is still pretty powerful in its
studio version, and Les Holroyd's "Hard Hearted Woman" also turned into
a concert favorite. The real highlight, however, is John Lees' "Poor
Man's Moody Blues," which manages to outdo the other band at their own
game. (British import)
Bruce Eder, All-Music Guide
Kritiker warfen BJH immer wieder vor schwülstig und kitschig zu
sein. Na und? Dieses Konzept geht auf "Gone To Earth" auf jeden Fall
auf. Die erfolgreichste Platte, die die englische Softrockgruppe je
hervorgebracht hat, wartet mit einer Reihe wunderschöner Songs
auf. Gleich zum Einstieg gibt`s DEN Klassiker "Hymn", gefolgt von der
schönen Ballade "Love Is Like A Violin". "Friend Of Mine" von Les
Holroyd klingt für mich etwas zu stark nach Country-Musik. Doch
danach ist wieder ein echter Klassiker zu hören: "Poor Man`s Moody
Blues"- Der Song war als Antwort von John Lees auf die ewigen
Vorwürfe der Kritiker gedacht, BJH würden wie die Moody Blues
für Arme klingen. Die Qualität der restlichen Songs
fällt zwar etwas ab, aber trotzdem bleibt der Gesamteindruck des
Albums absolut positiv.
Audio
A superb album already, Barclay James Harvest's 1977 Gone to Earth got
a lot better in this reissue edition. For starters (before we even get
to the bonus tracks that nearly double the running time of the original
LP), there's the sound -- the state-of-the-art remastering puts all of
the instruments practically right in your lap, but most especially John
Lees' various guitars and Stewart Wooly Wolstenholme's keyboards, which
get a really close sound. What's even better is the warmth of the
overall sound -- the vocals and the playing may be intense, but there's
an engaging, seductive richness to all of it, from Lees' electric lead
guitar runs on "Love Is Like a Violin" or Wolstenholme's Mellotron on
"Poor Man's Moody Blues," which offers some of the richest textures
ever heard from that too-often-forgotten instrument. The bonus tracks
open with an enjoyable outtake, "Lied," a previously unissued song
that's a good showcase for Lees' playing; "Our Kid's Kid" is a catchy,
upbeat B-side, with a great melody and a gorgeous overall texture
mixing electric/acoustic guitars on lead and rhythm, which might've
just worked as a "play" side; a previously unreleased single-edit of
the album opener, "Hymn," follows, that might just be even prettier
than the LP version, and heralds the single version of "Friend of
Mine," which is still one of the most hummable pieces of music ever to
come out of the whole art rock boom. It all ends with an 11-minute live
rendition of "Medicine Man" that showcases not only Lees' playing, but
also Les Holroyd's killer bass work and a performance by drummer Mel
Pritchard that's as dazzling to us as it must've been exhausting to
him. All of that, coupled with well-written and detailed annotation,
plus the lyrics, make this a must-own disc even for relatively casual
fans of the band -- indeed, this could be the best showcase of BJH's
overall range as any hits compilation that one is likely to find.
Bruce Eder All-Music Guide
Quintessential Harvest
For those of you who are unfamiliar with your rock history, Barclay
James Harvest were one of a long line of symphonic rock bands that were
swept away in 1976 when the storm broke. Once laughably unhip, it has
taken 20 years or more before their name can be mentioned in polite
society without being attacked with a pair of rusty scissors. A shame,
because they were not half bad. Favouring grandiose orchestral
arrangements they were often compared with the Moody Blues, but whereas
the Moodies' lyrics often consisted of meaningless twaddle, BJH's
beautiful melodies often fronted black social comment and realism.
Beneath the lushness, there was a simple, unpretentious approach to
songwriting best showcased on their 70s output and before the departure
of their keyboard player and one-man symphony orchestra, Woolly
Wolstenholme. Gone to Earth is the last of these. OK, the production
sounds a tad dated, but the fact still remains that the Barclay James
Harvest was a band whose 4 members complemented each other to produce a
well-balanced, homogenous sound. The material on Gone to Earth is
strong, and the highlights - Hymn, Sea of Tranquillity and Higher and
Higher - are beautiful, inspiring and crying out for rediscovery
Mons Gregemark from Stockholm , November 28, 2000
Be Different -- Don't Overlook this Masterpiece!
This is one of those true gems that commercialized radio swept under
the carpet -- choosing instead to play predictable swill, all in 4:4
time. Barclay James Harvest is a great band that has often released
'uneven' albums that haven't helped make their case as a great band.
But this album is at the top of the heap when it comes to brilliant
material. 'Hymn' and 'Poor Man's Moody Blues' are superb, as is Wooly
Wolstenholme's Mellotron-laced 'Sea of Tranquility.' A beautiful album;
lush, orchestral and at times very cutting -- this is the band at their
very best. Once you play this album, you'll see why many BJH fans have
stayed with the band from the late 60's until today. Be different --
don't overlook this orchestral rock masterpiece! Help correct the error
made by radio programmers in the late 70's.
theboomer from Cambria, California , May 25, 2000
BJH flies high on Gone To Earth.
A stunningly gorgeous album, Gone To Earth displays mid-period BJH at
their absolute peak. The band stumbled on Time Honored Ghosts, regained
their footing on the previous Octoberon, and sound downright brilliant
on this '77 release. Crank up the headphones and totally immerse
yourself in the beauty and lushness of this album: Hymn, the
unforgettable, mellotron-drenched leadoff track, Poor Man's Moody Blues
(a sly tweak at those who accused the band of mimmicking the Moodies),
the haunting Spirit On The Water, or keyboardist Woolie Wolstenholme's
epic Sea Of Tranquility. If you're into '70s progressive rock and want
to own one album by this long-standing British band, let it be Gone To
Earth.
A music fan from Warren, MI , September 23, 1998
Mellotron Musings from the World's Best Unknown Band
Barclay James Harvest, to all you folks who have never heard of them,
are a progressive rock band from England. They have been around since
the late 1960's, and have been recording albums since 1971. Their style
is very "Moody Blues-Procul Harem" like, featuring a lot of Mellotron
music. (A Mellotron is a kind of primitive synthasizer, or tape
sampling device) They also use conventional instruments, guitars, bass,
drums, and some of their earlier work featured a full orchestra. Gone
To Earth is one of their finest early albums, featuring the hits Hymn,
Poor Man's Moody Blues, and Love is Like a Violin. This is a majestic,
soaring, spiritual album which features the band at their very peak of
energy and excellence. I highly recomend it to anyone who enjoys
progressive rock, particularly Moody Blues fans. Barclay James Harvest
has a home page on the WWW, and a fan club based in England that
carries a lot of their out of print material. Check them out, you will
be glad that you took the time.
Jim Wilkins (jimwilkins@mailcity.com) from Linden, Virginia , June 23, 1998
A Musical Masterpiece
BJH have, as long as I've known the band, been compared to the Moody
Blues. A (very)old friend of mine once cynically referred them as being
a "watered down version of the Bee Gees" - I think not (to either
opinion)The ultimate tribute to a truly outstanding band was EMI naming
the Harvest label after them! Gone To Earth is the band at their very
best. Each track in its own way is outstanding. My personal favs are
(naturally) 'Hymn', 'Poor Man's Moody Blues', 'Sea Of Tranquility' and
'Spirit On The Water' - Hell - all of them! BJH almost made it big time
during the mid/late '70s, but tragically the music press at that time
were more interested in following the fortunes of the glam rock scene,
so BJH didn't get the coverage their music deserved.Personally, I
preferred them after they dumped the orchestra, thus allowing Stuart
Wolstenholme to demonstrate he's as good a keyboard man as Wakeman,
Emerson, Banks et al.I saw them around 1975 time in Glasgow's City
Halls, and they were superb!John Lees is a gifted guitarist and
songwriter, and Les Holroyd also played a major part as bassist and
songwriter. The album is timeless; it'll never grow old.After 23 years
it's still as good as it was when first released. I'd recommend it to
anyone.
wright_ag@hotmail.com from Aberdeen, Scotland 3 December, 2000
A timeless classic by one of the UK's most enduring bands
I bought this album over 20 years ago , it remains one of my most
listened to of an extensive collection. It encompasses all aspects of
British rock music of the time but most importantly remains 'timeless'.
The song 'Hymn' is a recognised classic and is one of the groups
'signiture tunes'. The group have continued to release albums and to
date in excess 20 (not including compliations etc).'Gone to Earth'is
therefore an excellent introduction . BJH's style is typically compared
to the Moody Blues. Be prepared to be impressed !
glr_john@hotmail.com from Hertfordshire 6 July, 2000
DAS Barclay James Harvest Album
Kritiker warfen BJH immer wieder vor schwülstig und kitschig zu
sein. Na und? Dieses Konzept geht auf "Gone To Earth" auf jeden Fall
auf. Die erfolgreichste Platte, die die englische Softrockgruppe je
hervorgebracht hat, wartet mit einer Reihe wunderschöner Songs
auf. Gleich zum Einstieg gibt`s DEN Klassiker "Hymn", gefolgt von der
schönen Ballade "Love Is Like A Violin". "Friend Of Mine" von Les
Holroyd klingt für mich etwas zu stark nach Country-Musik. Doch
danach ist wieder ein echter Klassiker zu hören: "Poor Man`s Moody
Blues"- Der Song war als Antwort von John Lees auf die ewigen
Vorwürfe der Kritiker gedacht, BJH würden wie die Moody Blues
für Arme klingen. Die Qualität der restlichen Songs
fällt zwar etwas ab, aber trotzdem bleibt der Gesamteindruck des
Albums absolut positiv.
markus-rupp@gmx.de , 21. August 2000
Einfach schön!
Jetzt ist es gepackt! Nach einem Dutzend Alben das ich hier bewertet
habe gibt es das erste Mal fünf Sterne. Zwar ist hier alles ein
wenig schmalzig geraten, aber das ist halt einmal der Stil von BJH. Und
was soll`s auch, Hauptsache ist, das einem das Ganze gefällt, und
das tut es. Gleich nach der Anfangssingle "Hymn" kommen noch insgesamt
vier Songs denen ich die beste Note in der Einzelbewertung geben
konnte. Aber holt euch das Album, das übrigens auch ein lohnendes
Cover hat, doch einfach und Ihr werdet feststellen: Einfach schön!
rastoul@gmx.de aus Zweibrücken in Rheinland-Pfalz , 6. Februar 2000
Gone To Earth
Das ist sie also: Die bekannteste CD von Barcley James Harvest. Auf der
„GONE TO EARTH" ist gleich als erstes Lied „HYMN" drauf.
Der absolute Klassiker der Gruppe und auch das beste Lied in der ganzen
Sammlung. Gute 5 Minuten geht es hier richtig überirdisch und auch
etwas bombastisch ab. Die Lautstärke und die Anzahl der
Instrumente steigert sich von Minute zu Minute. Auch einen guten Anteil
am Erfolg wie dem enormen Spassfaktor beim Zuhören hat mit
Sicherheit der Sänger im Zusammenspiel mit seinem Chor. Es kling
einfach genialbombastisch. Am besten richtig aufdrehen oder den
Kopfhörer aufsetzten. Leider gibt es grosse Unterschiede in der
musikalischen Qualität der Lieder. So ist erst das vierte
„Poor man´s moody blues" wieder richtig gut. Geht recht
ruhig zur Sache der Titel, ist aber gut geeignet zum Abschalten vom
Alltagsstress. Und zusammen mit dem tollen Cover ( Ein landender Vogel,
wahrscheinlich so was ähnliches wie ein UHU in surrealistischer
Landschaft, eingefasst in goldenem Rahmen ) ein gutes Geschenk für
Freunde.
Eine Hörerin oder ein Hörer aus Mainz-Bretzenheim , 3. Januar 2000
Irgendwie ist die Musik heute anders, aber nicht besser ...
Dies ist wirklich ein Fingerzeit aus einer anderen Zeit. Damals noch
weite Schlaghosen (hatten wir auch schon wieder), Glitzerklamotten und
einfach gute, normale Bands: Schlagzeug, Gitarre, Bass! Musik
tatsächlich noch handgemacht. Gut, das hört man dann auch,
die Aufnahmen sind dann eben nicht digital aufgenommen und manchmal
knistert es vielleicht auch, aber dafür - denke ich manchmal -
sind diese Songs wenigstens ehrlich. Nicht in Massenproduktion auf denn
Markt geworfen. Und jedes Stück anders, erzählt seine eigene
Geschichte.
Für mich einfach ein schönes Album mit jeder Menge (meist)
romantischen Songs, bei denen man sich gut mit der (dem) Liebsten
irgendwohin verkriechen kann und einfach nur schmusen möchte. Ganz
toll: "Hymn" und "Taking me higher"!
devries@uni-bremen.de aus Bremen , 25. Dezember 1999
Valley's deep and the mountain's so high
If you want to see God you've got to move on the other side
You stand up there with your head in the clouds
Don't try to fly you know you might not come down
Don't try to fly, dear God, you might not come down
Jesus came down from Heaven to earth
The people said it was a virgin birth
Jesus came down from Heaven to earth
The people said it was a virgin birth
He told great stories of the Lord
And said he was the saviour of us all
He told great stories of the Lord
And said he was the saviour of us all
For this they/we killed him, nailed him up high
He rose again as if to ask us why
Then he ascended into the sky
As if to say in God alone you soar
As if to say in God alone we fly.
Valley's deep and the mountain's so high
If you want to see God you've got to move on the other side
You stand up there with your head in the clouds
Don't try to fly you know you might not come down
Don't try to fly, dear God, you might not come down
Love was like a violin playing soft and low
In your heart you held the strings, in my heart the bow
Together we made soft sweet music, together we believed
In every day in every hour our love was everything
Love was like a summer breeze, after pouring rain
Blowing all the clouds away, bringing sun again
Together we made soft sweet music, together we believed
In every day in every hour our love was everything
First dance you were mine, first dance we made it
Last dance, last chance, you know I know you were wrong
You know you were wrong, you know for every feeling there's a song
You were like a mountain stream, flowing fast and free
You were like the autumn leaves blowing from my tree
Together we made soft sweet music, together we believed
In every day in every hour our love was everything
After all the leaves had gone, you were winter snow
You were so cold and far away, I had to let you go
Together we made soft sweet music, together we believed
In every day in every hour our love was everything
When the lights are fading slowly on another show
And the crowd has gone, the people cease to shout for more
You'd better run, stop from crying all the time
Don't you know it's got to end, I thought you were a friend of mine
Goodbye bright light city heading for the sun
Where the southern girls are pretty and there's two for one
You'd better run, stop from crying all the time
Don't you know it's got to end, I thought you were a friend of mine
All the nights that I've missed you
All the nights without end
All the times that I've called you
Only needing a friend
Now your eyes shine with beauty
That I missed long ago
Guess the truth is I love you
I can't say any more
'Cause I need you
Yes I want you
Yes I love you
As I look from my window
To the streets where you stand
I am gazing through dark glass
We can't walk hand in hand
Though your friends try to tell me
Though your friends you defend
They keep my heart from your heart
We must be in the end
'Cause I love you
Yes I need you
Yes I love you
All the nights that I've missed you
All the nights without end
All the times that I've called you
Only needing a friend
Now your eyes shine with beauty
That I missed long ago
Guess the truth is I love you
I can't say any more
'Cause I need you
Yes I want you
Yes I love you
She's a hard hearted woman
See the way that she's watching you
Victims falling before her
And there's nothing that you can do
Love comes, holding on to us all
Love comes, holding on to us all
See the hard hearted woman
Watch the way that she's dancing now
Eyes are flashing before you
Break her spell, please tell me how
Love comes, holding on to us all
Love comes, holding on to us all
We steered our ship to the Sea of all Tranquility
The only sound our voices, as star-struck we fly
Our hopes ever high
That the songs we sing and the words we bring
Should never die
We set our sights on the Sea of all Tranquility
Our pointless flight betraying now fallen we are
(Gods of old now broken and defaced)
Compared to a star
And the final reach to that barren beach
Is much too far
Yesterday our songs of glory shone
A dream of ages every one
We sold our souls for senseless gain
And brought our harvest home in vain
(Above the seven seas is one)
Yesterday our songs of glory shone
A dream of ages every one
We sold our souls for senseless gain
And brought our harvest home in vain
There's a spirit floating on the water
There's a shadow lying down by the shore
Wasn't he there a year before?
A sacrifice for the coat he's wearing
A 'paradise' for the lady
Who dares colour him red upon the shore?
We carry the burden upon our shoulder
We carry their lives in the palm of our hand
Don't you care about the state you're in
Or don't you understand?
See the spirit floating on the water
See the shadow lying down by the shore
Wasn't he there some years before?
We carry the burden upon our shoulder
We carry their lives in the palm of our hand
Don't you care about the state you're in
Or don't you understand?
Well I feel like I've come to the end of a long long road
My body's tired and my mind's got no place to go
The end of the line's where I'm at, 'cos there's nothing left to be
Just a burnt out case, God, the leper and me
Well i feel like I've come to the end of a long long day
The victim of a life that I tried to give away
A prisoner of the isles where there's nothing left to be
Just a burnt out case, God, the leper and me
Well I feel like I've come to the end of a long long road
My body's tired and my mind's got no place to go
The end of the line's where I'm at, 'cos there's nothing left to be
Just a burnt out case, God, the leper and me
Used to be a dreamer
But you know I've found
A better way - you
Thought I was a loser
But you proved me wrong
You're taking me so much higher
You're taking me so much higher